Netuality

Well, not all Twitter runs on Cassandra Alex Payne explains how they build Hawkwind, a distributed search system written in Scala. Take a look at the slide 18, where you can clearly see that they use HBase as backend:

Also from the great guys at Twitter: gizzard. Interesting and appropriate name for a database sharding framework. Gizzard uses range-based partitioning and replication tree and knows to rely on a large range of data stores: RDBMSes, Lucene or Redis – you name it. But I wonder about the operational overhead when you have a really large gizzard cluster.

Michael Stonebraker has a short essay on CAP published in the ACM blogs. He identifies a series of use cases where the CAP theorem simply does not apply and cannot be appealed to for guidance:

Obviously, one should write software that can deal with load spikes without failing; for example, by shedding load or operating in a degraded mode. Also, good monitoring software will help identify such problems early, since the real solution is to add more capacity. Lastly, self-reconfiguring software that can absorb additional resources quickly is obviously a good idea.

In summary, one should not throw out the C so quickly, since there are real error scenarios where CAP does not apply and it seems like a bad tradeoff in many of the other situations.

Great nosqlEu coverage on Alex Popescu’s blog MyNoSQL. Read it to get all the presentations, tons of links and Twitter quotes.

Because every self-respecting blog should mention some info about the newly released iPad, here’s mine. According to the O’Reilly Radar, iPad is not ready for the cloud integration:

I am hoping for a future where all I need to supply a device with is my identity, and everything else falls into place. This doesn’t even have to be me trusting in a third-party cloud: there’s no reason similar mechanisms couldn’t be used privately in a home network setting.

I think the iPad is an amazing piece of hardware, and the most pleasant web browsing experience available. It is still very much a 1.0 device though, and its best days certainly lie ahead of it. I hope part of that improvement is a simple story for synchronization and cloud access.

Guess I’ll be waiting for the release of iPad Pro:

Two great posts from my colleagues about why Adobe is using HBase: part 1 and part 2. As I’ve experienced all these firsthand, I guarantee this is solid, relevant information. Both articles are highly recommended reads.

Speaking about HBase, there’s rumor on the street that they are taking HBASE-1295 (multi data center replication) very seriously and we’ll be seeing a new feature announcement relatively soon. Waiting forward!

An older but still interesting presentation on how RIPE NCC is using Hadoop and HBase to store and search through IP addresses for Europe, Middle East and Russia can be found here:

It looks like Farmvile is still in the MySQL+memcache phase, according to the High Scalability blog. And they use PHP. When will they start looking into NoSQL? Hopefully soon enough to have a good crop.

Nathan’s visual guide to NoSQL systems while perhaps not entirely correct is a nice tentative to put all these projects on the same map. I would love to see a “patched” version of the visual guide taking into account all the information left in the comments…

Oh and Twitter is using Protocol Buffers to store information on Hadoop. And they’re going to opensource their implementation.

Good points (as always) on Alexandru’s blog discussing the SQL scalability isn’t for everyone topic.

NoSQL as RDBMS are just tools for our job and there is nothing about the death of one of the other. But as we’ve learned over years, every new programming language is the death of all its precursors, every new programming paradigm is the death of everything that existed before and so on. The part that some seem to be missing or ignoring deliberately is that in most of these cases this death have never really happened.

For large-scale performance testing of a production environment check out how Facebook MySpace simulated 1 million concurrent users with a huge EC2 cluster, described on the High Scalability blog. While the article is a guest post from a company selling “cloud testing” solutions and has a bit of “sales juice” in it, it’s still a very good read:

Someone is in love with Cassandra after only 4 months. Hoping Cassandra doesn’t get too fat after the wedding:

Traditional sharding and replication with databases like MySQL and PostgreSQL have been shown to work even on the largest scale websites — but come at a large operational cost. Setting up replication for MySQL can be done quickly, but there are many issues you need to be aware of, such as slave replication lag. Sharding can be done once you reach write throughput limits, but you are almost always stuck writing your own sharding layer to fit how your data is created and operationally, it takes a lot of time to set everything up correctly. We skipped that step all together and added a couple hooks to make our data aggregation service siphon to both PostgreSQL and Cassandra for the initial integration.

Distributed data war stories from Anders @ bandwidth.com, HBase and Hadoop on commodity hardware:

As mentioned before, the commodity machines I used were very basic but I was able to insert conservatively about 500 records per second with this setup. I kept blowing the circuit breaker at the office as well forcing me to spread the machines across several power circuits but it proved that the system was at least fault tolerant!

SourceForge chooses Python, TurboGears and … MongoDB for a new version of their website. Looks like Mongo is becoming quite mainstream.

Don’t believe the rumors, Oracle is into cloud computing after all – at least according to Forrester. Well, as long as the clouds are private. And as long as you can live with “coming soon” tooling. And it’s not like they really have a clear long-term strategy for cloud computing:

I believe that cloud is a revolution for Oracle, IBM, SAP, and the other big vendors with direct sales forces (despite what they say). Cloud computing has the potential to undermine the account-management practices and pricing models these big companies are founded on. I think it will take years for each of the big vendors to adapt to cloud computing. Oracle is just beginning this journey; I think other vendors are further down the track.

The igvita blog hits NoSQL in the groin by showing a simple way of having a schema-free data store … in MySQL. It’s a sort of proxy that translates schemas into denormalized data placed in distinct tables:

Instead of defining columns on a table, each attribute has its own table (new tables are created on the fly), which means that we can add and remove attributes at will. In turn, performing a select simply means joining all of the tables on that individual key. To the client this is completely transparent, and while the proxy server does the actual work, this functionality could be easily extracted into a proper MySQL engine – I’m just surprised that no one has done so already.

While an interesting idea, not sure how effective this will be in practice, as joins are among the most time-consuming operations in the database world. I’m pretty sure that replacing a 10-column table get on the primary key with joins on 10 tables will add an important overhead.

Seven signs you need to accept NoSQL in your life according to the High Scalability blog. I especially like sign #6 “Maintaining a completely separate object caching system on top of an already beefy table storage system“. There are companies making serious bucks from selling exactly this type of caching systems. I find that a bit ironic, don’t you?

Twitter has just decided to adopt Cassandra as their main storage. I roughly estimated the status table to having  more than 9 billion rows – it’s a good table size to start thinking about the benefits of NoSQL. I would have been interested in seeing a comparison with other existing solutions and a rationale of their choice. According to some sources, Ryan King rejected HBase because if a region server is down, writes will be blocked for affected data until the data is redistributed – unlike Cassandra’s “write never fail” policy. According to other sources, this will be solved in a future version of HBase but I think Twitter needed a solution sooner rather than later. I hope for two things:

• That the Twitter dudes will blog about their migration experience
• That I’ll be able to access and search through all my older tweets, fer’ God sake!

Forrester Research thinks that NoSQL and Elastic Caching Platforms are very similar. So similar that “NoSQL Wants To Be Elastic Caching When It Grows Up“. According to Forrester “Ultimately, the real difference between NoSQL and elastic caching now may be in-memory versus persistent storage on disk.” Yeah sure: transactions, durability, indexing, security model – who needs this crap anyway?

Oh and let’s not forget about today’s GAE unscheduled downtime. Waiting forward for the post mortem, for sure there will be a thing or two to learn…

Yes there is such a thing as cloud management services and Cloudkick has a business model around them:

The San Francisco company’s existing features — including a dashboard with an overview of your cloud infrastructure, email alerts, and graphs that you help you visualize data like bandwidth requirements — will always be free, said co-founder and chief executive Alex Polvi. But Cloudkick wants to charge for features on top of the basic service, such as SMS alerts when your app has problems and a change-log tool where sysadmins can communicate with each other, which Polvi described as “Twitter for servers.”

Great article on designing applications for the cloud from Godjo Adzic who spent his last two years in projects deployed on the Amazon cloud:

A very healthy way to look at this is that all your cloud applications will run on a bunch of cheap web servers. It’s healthy because planning for that in advance will help you keep your mental health when glitches occur, and it will also force you to design for machine failure upfront making the system more resilient.

Royans blog comments James Hamilton critical post about private clouds not being the future:

Though I believe in most of his comments, I’m not convinced with the generalization of the conclusions. In particular, what is the maximum number of servers one need to own, beyond which outsourcing will become a liability. I suspect this is not a very high number today, but will grow over time.

And a good detailed article about Hive used at Facebook:

Facebook has a production Hive cluster which is primarily used for log summarization, including aggregation of impressions, click counts and statistics around user engagement. They have a separate cluster for “Ad hoc analysis” which is free for all/most Facebook employees to use. And over time they figured out how to use it for spam detection, ad optimization and a host of other undocumented stuff.